Blog — D'Angelo Law Office, P.C.

The Colorado Supreme Court Abolishes The Sudden Emergency Doctrine

By Dan D'Angelo, Esq. · February 28, 2013

The Colorado Supreme Court has released its opinion in Bedor v. Johnson, No. 10SC65, abolishing the Sudden Emergency Doctrine from Colorado law.

What was the Sudden Emergency Doctrine? The now-former Sudden Emergency Doctrine was a defense sometimes asserted in negligence lawsuits when a person was confronted with sudden or unexpected circumstances that did not require them to exercise the same judgment as one acting under normal conditions. For example, a driver who hit an icy patch of road and caused injuries to another person could, depending on the circumstances, assert the Sudden Emergency Defense as an affirmative defense and request that the court give the following jury instruction: "A person who, through no fault of his or her own, is placed in a sudden emergency, is not chargeable with negligence if the person exercises that degree of care that a reasonably careful person would have exercised under the same or similar circumstances." CJI 9:11 (2012).

Why did the Colorado Supreme Court abolish the Sudden Emergency Doctrine? The Court abolished the doctrine because its potential to mislead the jury greatly outweighs its minimal utility. First, the sudden emergency jury instruction was found to be duplicative — other negligence instructions already cover the reasonable care standard under the circumstances, such as CJI 9:6 and 9:8. Second, the Court found the instruction misleading because it: (1) failed to instruct the jury to find two important facts before applying the doctrine, causing the jury to treat the instruction as an affirmation that a sudden emergency had in fact existed; (2) did not define the term "sudden emergency"; (3) implied that sudden emergency situations require a reduced standard of care; and (4) focused the jury's attention on events during and after the emergency rather than on the totality of the circumstances.

What does this mean for crash victims in Colorado? The negligent driver can no longer assert the Sudden Emergency Doctrine as an affirmative defense, and trial courts may no longer give jury instruction 9:11 at trial.

The Colorado Supreme Court's full opinion in Bedor v. Johnson is available on the court's website at www.courts.state.co.us under Case Announcements.

Denver skyline reflected in a lake
D'Angelo Law Office, P.C.

D'Angelo Law Office, P.C., 3000 Lawrence St., #23, Denver, Colorado 80205

The legal information provided on this website is general in nature and is not a substitute for the consultation of a licensed attorney in your state. Legal advice cannot be given without full consideration of all the relevant information applicable to an individual's personal set of circumstances. Daniel E. D'Angelo, Esq., 3000 Lawrence St., #23 Denver, Colorado 80205, is responsible for the content of this Website. For additional disclosures please read our Terms of Use.

© 2026 D'Angelo Law Office, P.C. All rights reserved.

Also operating as Bike Brain Law, a dedicated practice division for bicycle and brain injury.