Blog — D'Angelo Law Office, P.C.

Sending a Text Message (Even While Not Driving) Could Make You Liable for a Car Crash

By Dan D'Angelo, Esq. · August 29, 2013

A New Jersey Appellate Court, in an August 27, 2013 opinion, provided a glimpse into the future where the sender of a text message — who is not driving — could be held liable for a crash caused by the recipient of that text message.

In Kubert v. Best, et al., Docket No. A-1128-12T4, Superior Court of New Jersey Appellate Division (August 27, 2013), David and Linda Kubert each lost a leg after a driver who was texting crossed the center line and struck them on their motorcycle. The Kuberts appealed the trial court's dismissal of their claim against the defendant driver's friend — who was not in the vehicle at the time but had sent the driver a text message immediately before the crash and distracted him. The Appellate Division held that "the sender of a text message can potentially be liable if a crash is caused by texting, but only if the sender knew or had special reason to know that the recipient would view the text while driving and thus be distracted."

The plaintiffs' case did not survive summary judgment because, despite both parties exchanging numerous text messages throughout the day of the collision, there was insufficient direct or circumstantial evidence that the sender knew the recipient was driving at the time and would read the message while behind the wheel, in violation of New Jersey's hands-free law.

The plaintiffs argued that the sender "aided and abetted" the recipient's violation of New Jersey law by sending the text. Similar arguments arise in cases involving drunk drivers, where someone who knew the driver had been drinking allowed them to drive anyway. In this case, however, the sender did not have a "special relationship" with the recipient — such as an employer-employee or parent-child relationship — that would give her control over his conduct. The court also held that merely sending a text message was not sufficient encouragement for the recipient to read and respond immediately while driving. There would need to be evidence that the sender urged the recipient to read and respond while driving, and no such evidence existed.

Despite the plaintiffs' loss, the New Jersey Appellate Court appears to have laid down the first test of its kind: given the right evidence, a third party who sends a text message to a driver could be held liable if the driver causes a crash because of the distraction. It is a legal development worth watching as texting-while-driving cases continue to evolve.

Denver skyline reflected in a lake
D'Angelo Law Office, P.C.

D'Angelo Law Office, P.C., 3000 Lawrence St., #23, Denver, Colorado 80205

The legal information provided on this website is general in nature and is not a substitute for the consultation of a licensed attorney in your state. Legal advice cannot be given without full consideration of all the relevant information applicable to an individual's personal set of circumstances. Daniel E. D'Angelo, Esq., 3000 Lawrence St., #23 Denver, Colorado 80205, is responsible for the content of this Website. For additional disclosures please read our Terms of Use.

© 2026 D'Angelo Law Office, P.C. All rights reserved.

Also operating as Bike Brain Law, a dedicated practice division for bicycle and brain injury.