Blog — D'Angelo Law Office, P.C.

Why Crash Victims May Want to Remain Silent

By Dan D'Angelo, Esq. · December 31, 2013

Most people know about the constitutional right to remain silent when accused of a crime. Although a claim for bodily injuries and other damages resulting from a car crash is a civil tort and not a crime, and the insurance company is not the police or a prosecutor, most crash victims are unaware that they have no obligation to give the negligent driver's insurance company a statement or answer their questions about the crash.

Remember that insurance is a business, and the other driver's insurance company is working to maximize its own economic bottom line by paying you as little as possible. While you may think you are having a harmless and informal conversation about the crash with the other driver's insurance company, it is anything but informal — the adjuster is either recording everything you say or taking notes. You may unwittingly provide information they are not entitled to, you may misunderstand their questions and give an incorrect response, or the information you provide may be inaccurate for any number of reasons, such as not remembering clearly but feeling embarrassed and answering anyway. The insurance company may then use this information to improperly minimize or deny your claim.

The negligent driver's insurance company will likely try to contact you as soon as possible — usually within days of the crash — to gather as much information as it can before you are able to speak with an attorney. To avoid these mistakes, it is in your best interest to remain silent until you can speak with a Colorado personal injury attorney. All too often, crash victims come to us after it is too late, having already volunteered information the insurance company had no right to know, or having given inaccurate responses about the crash or their injuries. Instead of trying the do-it-yourself approach and hoping for the best, remain silent until you can speak with and hire an attorney to represent you.

This is not a constitutional or statutory right to remain silent, and you cannot remain silent indefinitely. There are time limits called statutes of limitations to bring your claim — if those deadlines pass, your claim may be barred entirely. You should not wait to contact an attorney to help you resolve your claim. For more information about hiring us, visit our FAQs or Contact Us pages.

Denver skyline reflected in a lake
D'Angelo Law Office, P.C.

D'Angelo Law Office, P.C., 3000 Lawrence St., #23, Denver, Colorado 80205

The legal information provided on this website is general in nature and is not a substitute for the consultation of a licensed attorney in your state. Legal advice cannot be given without full consideration of all the relevant information applicable to an individual's personal set of circumstances. Daniel E. D'Angelo, Esq., 3000 Lawrence St., #23 Denver, Colorado 80205, is responsible for the content of this Website. For additional disclosures please read our Terms of Use.

© 2026 D'Angelo Law Office, P.C. All rights reserved.

Also operating as Bike Brain Law, a dedicated practice division for bicycle and brain injury.